Short answer: Prop 65 does not ban any cosmetic ingredient. It requires a "clear and reasonable" warning when a product can expose a California consumer to a listed chemical above the safe-harbour level — or evidence that it cannot. The exposure assessment, not the label, is the real work.

Brands usually meet Prop 65 in one of two ways: a retailer asks for a warning on the artwork two weeks before launch, or a 60-day notice arrives from a plaintiff's firm. Both are downstream of the same missing artefact — a documented view of which listed chemicals could be present in the product and at what exposure.

This guide covers the mechanism, the chemicals that actually matter for cosmetics, the 2025 short-form warning change and its 2028 deadline, and the three routes that reduce exposure to enforcement.

The mechanism, in five points

  1. It is a right-to-know law, not a safety standard. No product is banned. The obligation is to warn before exposure, or to show that exposure is below the safe-harbour level.
  2. Enforcement is largely private. The Attorney General, district attorneys and city attorneys can act, and so can private individuals acting in the public interest — but a private plaintiff must serve a 60-day notice of violation first. Most settlements begin with that letter.
  3. Penalties are per violation per day. The statutory maximum is $2,500 per violation per day, which is why settlements are negotiated against a theoretical exposure rather than a real harm.
  4. Small businesses are exempt. Businesses with fewer than 10 employees are exempt from the warning requirement, but that exemption does not travel up the supply chain — a larger retailer can still require a warning contractually.
  5. Online sales are covered. For e-commerce, the warning must appear on the product display page, through a clearly marked hyperlink, or otherwise be prominently displayed before the purchase is completed.

The practical reading: a Chinese manufacturer shipping to a US brand is not the regulated party, but the brand's compliance file depends on documents only the manufacturer can provide — full formula with percentages, supplier declarations, heavy-metal test reports and packaging material specs.

The chemicals that actually matter in cosmetics

Prop 65 list includes more than 900 substances and is updated at least annually. For cosmetics, the recurring categories are narrower than the list:

Category Where it hides Why it triggers
Lead Pigments, mica, talc, some zinc oxide grades, metal components Listed; low safe-harbour level; common in colour cosmetics testing
Cadmium Pigment impurities, some clays Listed as carcinogen
Phthalates Fragrance carriers, plastic packaging, nail products Several listed as reproductive toxicants
Formaldehyde and releasers Preservatives in water-based products Listed as carcinogen
Titanium dioxide, respirable unbound particles Loose powders, sprays, pressed powders Listed for the inhalation route only
Crystalline silica, respirable Loose powders, some clays Listed for the inhalation route
Diethanolamine Foam boosters, pH adjusters Listed; relevant where nitrosamine risk exists
Bisphenol A and related Some plastic packaging, thermal paper Listed; packaging migration route

Two of these are frequently misread. Titanium dioxide and crystalline silica are listed for the airborne, respirable route, not for skin contact — which makes a loose powder or a spray a different risk case from a cream, even with the same pigment. And lead is not a permissible ingredient anywhere; it appears as an impurity, which is why the useful question is not "does the formula contain lead" but "what is the measured level in the pigment lot, and what does that mean for daily exposure".

What changed in 2025, and the 2028 deadline

The short-form warning was amended with effect from 1 January 2025. Three changes matter:

  • The chemical must be named. "WARNING: This product can expose you to chemicals known to the State of California to cause cancer" is no longer sufficient in the new short form. The warning must identify at least one listed chemical and the risk type.
  • The signal word options expanded. "WARNING", "CA WARNING" and "CALIFORNIA WARNING" are all acceptable, in capital letters and bold.
  • The transition runs to 1 January 2028. Products manufactured and labelled before that date may be sold with the old short-form warning indefinitely. Products manufactured and labelled from 1 January 2028 must use the new content.

For a brand launching in 2026, the sensible plan is to adopt the new short form now rather than plan a label change in 2027. Artwork revisions, print runs and inventory turns take longer than the calendar suggests.

Three routes to compliance

Route 1: reformulate or respecify. Remove the pathway rather than warn about it. Switch to a pigment supplier with a lower heavy-metal profile, drop a phthalate-containing fragrance carrier, replace a formaldehyde releaser with a different preservation system. This is the cheapest route over a product's life and the slowest to execute.

Route 2: exposure assessment. Measure the chemical in the finished product and calculate daily exposure against the safe-harbour level. For lead, the maximum allowable dose level is 0.5 micrograms per day; other chemicals have their own values. If exposure sits below the level, no warning is required — but the assessment has to be documented, defensible and specific to your use pattern.

Route 3: warn. Accept the warning and print it. This is legitimate, but it has commercial cost: a warning on a skincare product changes consumer perception, and some retailers refuse the listing. It also does not protect against a plaintiff arguing the warning was inadequate.

Most brands end up combining routes — respecify where it is easy, assess where the level is genuinely low, warn where neither is possible.

The documents the brand will ask you for

A Prop 65 file that survives a retailer review contains:

  • Full formula with INCI names and percentages, and the supplier of each pigment and fragrance.
  • Heavy-metal test reports (lead, cadmium, mercury, arsenic) on pigments and on the finished product, from an accredited laboratory.
  • Supplier declarations for fragrance and preservative systems, covering phthalates and formaldehyde releasers.
  • Packaging material specification, including any plastic components that contact the product.
  • A written exposure assessment or a documented decision to warn.

Our batch documents and CoA explainer covers which of these travel with each shipment; Prop 65 files are usually a separate, product-level set rather than a batch-level one.

Prop 65 is not MoCRA

The two are frequently conflated in supplier questionnaires. MoCRA is the federal FDA framework: facility registration, product listing, adverse event reporting, and safety substantiation. Prop 65 is a California exposure-warning law enforced mostly by private plaintiffs. A product can be fully MoCRA-compliant and still attract a Prop 65 notice, and vice versa. If your US compliance plan has one line item for "US compliance", it is missing one of them — the MoCRA checklist covers the federal side.

State-level bans are a separate track

California, Washington, Colorado, Maryland and others have enacted ingredient bans that go beyond Prop 65, with phased effective dates running into 2027. Those laws prohibit ingredients; Prop 65 warns about exposure. A formula that is compliant with a state ban can still require a Prop 65 warning for a different substance, and a formula that carries a warning is not thereby banned. Our state ingredient ban timeline maps the effective dates.

Where brands lose time

  • Leaving the exposure question to the retailer. The retailer will ask for a document; if none exists, the default answer becomes a warning on every SKU.
  • Assuming EU compliance covers California. REACH restrictions and Prop 65 overlap on some substances but differ on thresholds and on the legal mechanism.
  • Testing the finished product only. Pigment lots vary; a single finished-product test can miss a hot lot. Supplier-level testing with lot traceability is stronger evidence.
  • Printing the old short form in 2027. The old content remains valid only for product manufactured and labelled before 1 January 2028.
  • Forgetting the packaging. Plastic components and printed inserts can carry phthalates and BPA-related substances, which brings the package into scope even when the formula is clean.

FAQ

Q: Does Prop 65 apply to a cosmetic made and sold outside California? A: It applies to businesses that expose people in California, so any product sold into the state is in scope, including through e-commerce. The warning must be visible before the online purchase is completed.

Q: Can a Prop 65 warning be avoided by testing below the limit? A: Yes, if the measured exposure sits below the safe-harbour level for that chemical and the assessment is documented. For lead the maximum allowable dose level is 0.5 micrograms per day; other chemicals have their own values.

Q: Is titanium dioxide in a pressed powder a Prop 65 issue? A: The listing covers airborne, respirable unbound particles. A pressed powder with bound particles presents a different exposure case from a loose powder or a spray, which is why the product form matters to the assessment.

Q: Who is liable if a Chinese factory supplies the formula and a US brand sells the product? A: The warning obligation sits with the business selling into California, but enforcement usually reaches the brand and the retailer. The manufacturer's role is to supply accurate formula, supplier and test documentation.

Q: How long does a Prop 65 exposure assessment take? A: Testing plus calculation is typically four to eight weeks once the formula and supplier data are complete, and it has to be redone when a pigment supplier or fragrance changes.